We moved to 125 E 3rd St on the southside in Bethlehem!
About Paranormal Pizza
Paranormal Pizza: Where Flavor Meets the Supernatural
At Paranormal Pizza, we craft unforgettable, plant-based pizzas with bold flavors and a touch of the unknown. Born from a passion for great food and a love for the eerie and unexplained, we elevate traditional pizza to the next level with our unique Paranormal Pizza menu featuring house-made ingredients, innovative recipes, and a commitment to quality.
Our menu includes Detroit-style and classic thin-crust pies, made with scratch-made sourdough, vegan cheeses, and unique toppings—from our signature Seitan Sausage & Pepperoni to limited-edition specials like the Big Mac Pizza. Whether you’re a die-hard vegan, a pizza enthusiast, or just someone looking for a hauntingly good meal, our vegan pizza options in Bethlehem, PA, are sure to delight.
📍 Paranormal Pop-Ups: After a fire displaced us in February 2023, we’ve been working hard to keep Paranormal Pizza alive while we rebuild our home base. For now, you can find us popping up at Jay’s Local in Allentown—Friday evenings and Sundays with our signature plant-based pizzas.
🚚 Food Truck Season: In the spring, summer, and fall, we hit the road with our 100% plant-based sandwiches and more!
🔮 Stay in the loop—follow us on Instagram for updates!
Join us for a pizza experience like no other—because great food should be a little mysterious.
Delicious moments at Paranormal Pizza
